How the ratings work
How the ratings work: refund terms 30%, refills 20%, login rule 20%, price 15% and support 15%, the bands inside each, and what happens to unstated terms.
The five categories
- Refund terms30%
- Refill or delivery guarantee20%
- Login rule20%
- Price15%
- Support channels named15%
Refund terms · 30%
| What the seller states | Points |
|---|---|
| A written money-back window of 30 days or more | 100 |
| A window of 14 to 29 days | 85 |
| A refund of the month if growth falls short, checked after the first days | 85 |
| A window of 7 to 13 days | 70 |
| A window under 7 days | 50 |
| Refund only when an order is not delivered | 60 |
| A guarantee named without terms | 20 |
| No refunds | 0 |
When a seller's own pages give two windows, the longer written one counts and the conflict is shown on the card. Windows that cover only an accidental charge or an order not yet started are not refund terms. When the same terms rule out fully delivered orders, the window is capped at the "only when an order is not delivered" band.
Refill or delivery guarantee · 20%
| What the seller states | Points |
|---|---|
| A refund promised if growth or delivery falls short | 100 |
| A written refill window of a year or more | 100 |
| Refills for 90 days or more | 85 |
| Refills for 30 to 89 days | 70 |
| Refills for under 30 days | 50 |
| Refills named without a length | 40 |
| No refill on the tier priced | 0 |
Money back when the result falls short ranks with the longest refills: the buyer is made whole either way. A refill given only on some tiers is read for the tier the price comes from.
Login rule · 20%
| What the seller states | Points |
|---|---|
| Username only, no password | 100 |
| Password or login asked | 0 |
Price · 15%
| What the seller states | Points |
|---|---|
| Packages: $10 or less per 1,000 | 100 |
| $15 or less per 1,000 | 80 |
| $25 or less per 1,000 | 60 |
| $40 or less per 1,000 | 40 |
| Over $40 per 1,000 | 20 |
| Monthly plans: $40 or less per month | 100 |
| $70 or less per month | 80 |
| $100 or less per month | 60 |
| $200 or less per month | 40 |
| Over $200 per month | 20 |
Each pricing model is banded on its own scale, inside a single list: packs by their price per 1,000 (the 1,000 pack, or the listed pack closest to that size), monthly plans by the cheapest monthly price shown for the platform the list covers. A likes list is never compared with a followers list.
Support channels named · 15%
| What the seller states | Points |
|---|---|
| Three or more channels named | 100 |
| Two channels | 70 |
| One channel | 40 |
| Round-the-clock claimed, no channel named | 20 |
Terms a seller does not state
When a seller states nothing for a category, that category drops out of its rating and the remaining weights are scaled back up to 100. The page prints "Not stated" there; a silent seller is never marked down for it.
Order on every list
Editor's picks are chosen by our editors; all other services are ordered by score.
Each buyer list opens with the picks as a separate block, labeled "Editor's pick", showing a rating but no rank number. The numbered ranking below it runs from the top score down; services with equal ratings keep a fixed order that is identical on every list. The only superlative label appears on the service that holds the top score of that list; a lowest price or longest refill is stated as a figure with the seller named. Before anything is published, a build check recomputes each rating from the dataset and refuses to publish if a list's order and its ratings disagree.
Where the inputs come from
Every input is a seller's own page: the price table, the refund and refill terms, the contact page. Each value carries the page it was read from and the read date, and the desk re-reads every seller weekly. See the dataset.
The desk: who writes and checks · about the site · report a wrong figure · what this site collects · how you may reuse the data